Apple Watch 4 vs 5: Should you buy the Series 4?

Apple Watch 4 vs 5: Should you buy the Series 4?



The introduction of the Apple Watch Series 5 brought some changes to the overall Watch lineup. In previous years we’ve seen Apple release a new model of the watch, and also keep the previous years model available. However, this most recent release brought the Series 5, and it also saw the Series 4 get taken out of the lineup. Apple is currently selling the Watch Series 5 alongside the Watch Series 3.

Apple may have stopped selling the Series 4, but depending on your needs and preference, the Series 4 may actually be the better buy.

Apple did add some new features on the Watch Series 5, and one of those was a feature that many had been wanting for quite some time — the always-on display. But key features, such as the battery life, are the same on the Series 4 and Series 5. That brings the question of whether you should get the Series 5, or save some money and get a Series 4.

New features in Apple Watch Series 5

The overall look and feel of the Series 4 and the Series 5 are the same, however, the Series 5 is available in a few additional materials. The Series 4 was available in aluminum or stainless steel. The Series 5 remains available in aluminum and stainless steel, and Apple also introduced titanium and reintroduced ceramic.

Another change, and one that is not immediately obvious, is the internal storage. Apple bumped the internal storage space from 16GB on the Series 4 to 32GB on the Series 5. This may not be as important to all users, but if you are the type that likes to save music to your watch for offline playback — this could be rather helpful.

Otherwise, the three key new features that arrived with the Apple Watch Series 5 include the always-on display, the compass, and the international emergency calling.

Always-on Display

The always-on retina display is, perhaps, the most welcomed of the new features. Apple has said the always-on display is courtesy of “several advanced technologies” working together. These technologies include an “ultra-low power display driver, efficient power management integrated circuit and new ambient light sensor.”

Essentially, this means the time (and other important information) will always be visible on the retina display. The time will be displayed on a dim display when the wrist is down, and go back to regular brightness when the wrist is raised. And, perhaps equally important as the always-on display — is that it does not take a huge chunk of battery life. Apple has said the Watch Series 5 will have up to 18-hours of battery life, which is the same as the Watch Series 4.

Compass

The addition of the built-in compass includes a stand-alone Compass application, as well as three Compass complications. The Compass means users will be able to see which direction they are heading, along with the incline, the current elevation, and latitude and longitude.

International Emergency Calling

The feature will obviously be more important if you are a world traveler and it requires you to have a cellular model Watch Series 5, as opposed to a GPS-only model. But the good news is that this feature will work regardless of where the watch was purchased, or whether or not the user has the cellular service activated. Basically, the international emergency calling means users will be able to call emergency services if needed, without needing to know the local number for emergency services. The international emergency calling functionality also ties in with the Emergency SOS fall detection.

*****

The Apple Watch Series 5 brought some decent new features, though not all of the features will be as important to everyone. Not all users will need or care about the international emergency calling, and some may not care about the added internal storage or the compass. Out of the new features, we suspect the main perk of getting a Series 5 (over the Series 4) will be tied to the always-on display.

Apple Watch Series 4

This is where we go back to the earlier question — should you get a Series 5, or save some money and get a Series 4? Well…how important is an always-on display?

Outside of the three new features we just covered, the specs are largely the same between the Series 4 and the Series 5 Apple smartwatch.

Specs: Series 4 vs Series 5

Series 4 (40mm) Series 4 (44mm) Series 5 (40mm) Series 5 (44mm)
Finishes (GPS only) Alumimum Alumimum Alumimum Alumimum
Finishes (GPS + Cellular) Alumimum, Stainless Steel Alumimum, Stainless Steel Alumimum, Stainless Steel, Titanium, Ceramic Alumimum, Stainless Steel, Titanium, Ceramic
Display 324 x 394, 759 sq mm, 1000 nits 324 x 394, 759 sq mm, 1000 nits 324 x 394, 759 sq mm, 1000 nits 324 x 394, 759 sq mm, 1000 nits
Processor S4 with 64-bit dual core (W3 wireless) S4 with 64-bit dual core (W3 wireless) S5 with 64-bit dual core (W3 wireless) S5 with 64-bit dual core (W3 wireless)
Measurements 40 (H) x 34 (W) x 10.7 (D) mm 44 (H) x 38 (W) x 10.7 (D) mm 40 (H) x 34 (W) x 10.7 (D) mm 44 (H) x 38 (W) x 10.7 (D) mm
Weight 39.8g (stainless steel), 30.1g (aluminum) 47.9g (stainless steel), 36.7g (aluminum) 40.6g (stainless steel), 30.8g (aluminum), 35.1g (titanium), 39.7g (ceramic) 47.8g (stainless steel), 36.5g (aluminum), 41.7g (titanium), 46.7g (ceramic)

Both the Series 4 and the Series 5 include a battery life of up to 18 hours along with WiFi 802.11b/g/n and Bluetooth 5.0. The cellular models also include LTE and UMTS. Both models also have an LTPO OLED Retina display with force touch. Of course, as we mentioned earlier, the Series 5 has the always-on capability. Other shared features of the Series 4 and Series 5 Apple smartwatches break down as follows:

  • GPS, GLONASS, Galileo, QZSS
  • Barometric altimeter
  • Water resistant to 50 meters
  • Electrical heart sensor
  • Acceleromter (up to 32 g-forces)
  • Gyroscope
  • Ambient light sensor
  • Emergency SOS (fall detection)
  • Speaker
  • Microphone
  • Apple Pay
  • GymKit

Feature differences between the Series 4 and Series 5 are as follows:

  • Storage: Series 4 (16GB) / Series 5 (32GB)
  • Compass: Not found on the Series 4, was added on the Series 5.
  • International Emergency Calling: Not found on the Series 4, was added on the cellular model Series 5.
  • Optical heart sensor: Found on the both models, however the Series 5 has a second-generation optical heart sensor.

Pricing: Series 4 vs Series 5

With Apple discontinuing the Series 4 with the introduction of the Series 5 it is hard to compare current retail pricing. However, both the Series 4 and the Series 5 original retail pricing was the same — from $399 for the GPS model, and from $499 for the GPS + Cellular model. Of course, if you are looking to buy a newish Series 4 (or Series 5) Apple Watch — you do not have to worry about paying full retail price.

Prices here on Swappa will vary based on the condition of the watch, whether Mint, Good, or Fair. Current pricing (as of February 2020) shows the Apple Watch Series 4 40mm with prices ranging from $228 – $399. The Apple Watch Series 4 44mm is roughly the same on the low-end, with prices coming in a bit higher on the top-end, which is due to the 44mm being available in stainless steel (in addition to aluminum).

 

BUY APPLE WATCH SERIES 4 40MM

BUY APPLE WATCH SERIES 4 44MM

 

Current pricing (as of February 2020) shows the Apple Watch Series 5 40mm with prices ranging from $325 – $600. Similar to the Series 4, the Apple Watch Series 5 44mm is priced roughly the same on the low-end, with higher prices on the top-end, which again, is due to the 44mm being available in several different case materials (in addition to aluminum).

 

BUY APPLE WATCH SERIES 5 40MM

BUY APPLE WATCH SERIES 5 44MM

 

Value: Series 4 vs Series 5

Average sale prices for the Apple Watch Series 4 as of January 2020 show as $274 for the 40mm and as $290 for the 44mm.

Average sale prices for the Apple Watch Series 5 as of January 2020 show as $376 for the 40mm and as $405 for the 44mm.